As an Amazon Associate, earn from qualifying purchases
Name | Feature | Rating | Price |
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail | Self-sealing system | 4.7 out of 5 | |
Purifyou All Natural Diaper Pail Deodorizer | Hypoallergenic and eco-friendly | 4.1 out of 5 | |
The best safe option is the Dekor Plus Hands | Childproof design for added safety. | 4.6 out of 5 | |
Busch Systems Odorless Gallon Diaper Pail | Lightweight and durable | 4.2 out of 5 | |
Playtex Diaper Genie | Built-in carbon filter for odor control | 4.6 out of 5 | |
The most versatile pail is the Safety 1st Easy Saver diaper pail | Lightweight and sturdy construction | 4.4 out of 5 | |
Safety 1st Easy Saver diaper pail | Thick fabric prevents leaks | 4.8 out of 5 | |
Biloban Diaper Pail Liner | Thick material and strong elastic | 4.7 out of 5 | |
Teamoy Reusable Pail Liner | Thick and durable material for odor containment | 4.7 out of 5 | |
Ninja Mama Bamboo Carbon Charcoal Diaper Pail Filter | Biodegradable and eco-friendly | 3.8 out of 5 |
Diapering your little one is a daily task that every parent faces. While disposable diapers are convenient, many families are turning to cloth diapers for their eco-friendly and cost-effective benefits. If you’re one of those parents using cloth diapers, you know that managing soiled diapers can be a challenge. That’s where cloth diaper pails and liners come into play.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore the best cloth diaper pail, liners, and deodorizers of 2023 to help you make an informed decision. We’ll cover various options, their features, and community feedback to ensure you choose the right one for your needs.
Let’s examine each item’s specifics : best diaper pail for cloth diapers

Munchkin Step Diaper Pail: The Best Dry Pail for Odor Control
If odor control is a top priority for you, the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail is an excellent choice. This discreet pail includes a scented Arm & Hammer baking soda puck to keep odors at bay. You can easily swap it out for other scented pucks as needed. The self-sealing system ensures that nasty odors stay trapped inside. Plus, the hands-free design allows you to open the lid with a simple step on the lever, making diaper changes a breeze.
PROS
CONS
Community Feedback: “I’m quite pleased with this diaper pail’s performance in odor control and capacity.”
Purifyou All Natural Diaper Pail Deodorizer: Eco-Friendly Odor Control
To combat diaper pail odors effectively, the Purifyou All Natural Diaper Pail Deodorizer is a reliable choice. These large, porous granules are eco-friendly and help eliminate odors. You can tape them under your diaper pail lid or lay them in the bottom if you use a liner. These deodorizers offer hypoallergenic odor control and can be recharged by the sun for extended use.
PROS
CONS
Community Feedback: My main objective when I originally bought these charcoal sacks was to get rid of the overwhelming smell from my storage bag. To my astonishment, the scent was nearly entirely eliminated an hour after I put a sack inside the bag. A few hours in the sun can also revive a depleted sack, and with 12 supplied, I can be sure to always smell fresh. These bags have also been helpful to me in controlling odors in other places, such as diaper pails and litter boxes. I like that this product is all-natural and durable, making it a dependable remedy for different odor issues.
The best safe option is the Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail.
The Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail is a compact and stylish option for your nursery. It comes in various modern colors to match your decor. This pail offers triple odor control with rubber seals, odor-resistant plastic, and multiple child locks for safety. It’s perfect for parents who need their hands free during diaper changes. The product comes pre-assembled and is suitable for both cloth and disposable diapers.
PROS
CONS
Community Feedback : I noticed right away when I initially started using this diaper pail how simple it was to empty without wasting bags. After three years, I’m still blown away by how convenient it is. Unless there is a particularly stinking diaper inside, it performs a decent job of containing scents even though it doesn’t completely seal in odors. I like the foot pedal for the hands-free opening and the ease with which the bag blade makes cutting and changing bags. But over time, even after washing, I’ve found that the pail has started to retain some scents.
The best odor-containing pail is the Busch Systems Odorless Gallon Diaper Pail.
The Busch Systems Odorless Gallon Diaper Pail excels in containing odors, making it an excellent choice for cloth diapers. Its large opening accommodates even the bulkiest diapers without squeezing them through. The lightweight yet sturdy design allows for easy mobility. The odor-free carbon filters and double-sided lid seal ensure a tight closure and combat mold while containing odors effectively. This pail is suitable for both dry and wet pail methods.
PROS
CONS
Community Feedback: “I’m extremely pleased with this odorless cloth diaper pail, as it effectively contains all the unpleasant smells from my baby’s soiled diapers.”
Playtex Diaper Genie: Best Small Diaper Pail
The Playtex Diaper Genie, originally designed for disposable diapers, also works well with cloth diapers. It features built-in odor-controlling antimicrobial agents, double airtight clamps, and a carbon filter to eliminate odors effectively. This tall and narrow pail takes up minimal space and is perfect for small nurseries. Its hands-free opening mechanism and easy-to-empty bin make diaper changes a breeze.
PROS
CONS
Community Feedback: “This diaper genie has been an essential addition to our nursery, with its space-saving design and ease of use.”
The most versatile pail is the Safety 1st Easy Saver diaper pail.
The Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail is perfect if you’re unsure about using the wet or dry pail method. This versatile pail can accommodate both methods and works with any kind of plastic liners. It’s lightweight, weighing only two pounds, making it easy to move around the nursery or home. The no-bend, no-twist design allows for easy diaper disposal.
PROS
CONS
Community Feedback: For my family, this diaper pail has served as a dependable and economical solution for several kids over the years. It’s great that it works with common kitchen rubbish bags, cutting out the need for more expensive specialty bags. The pail functions well overall, despite the smell discs’ average effectiveness. It is not only excellent for disposing of diapers but also cat excrement and soiled underwear. This diaper pail is a useful addition to any home with young children, despite the fact that the trash chute is a little on the small side.
Related Post : Ubbi diaper pail how to use
Safety 1st Easy Saver diaper pail: Best Washable Liner
When it comes to choosing a reusable diaper pail liner, the Alvababy Reusable Diaper Pail Liner stands out. Its waterproof design ensures no leaks, and it can hold up to 20-25 diapers. This liner is easy to attach to most diaper pails, preventing accidental slips. You can transport your diapers from the pail to the laundry without getting your hands dirty. The best part? It’s machine washable for easy cleaning.
PROS
CONS
Community Feedback: “I’m thrilled with these reusable recycling bags, as they’ve made my recycling process more efficient and eco-friendly.”
Biloban Diaper Pail Liner: Best Affordable Liners
The Biloban Diaper Pail Liners offer great value for your money, as they come in a pack of two. These machine-washable liners are perfect for busy parents who want a backup liner when one is in the wash. They feature strong stitching to prevent leaks and fit most diaper pails and trash cans up to 13 gallons in size.
PROS
CONS
Community Feedback: I’ve had largely favorable experiences with these wet bags because they work well to trap moisture and minimize odors when used with cloth diapers. Large and sturdy, the bags include elastic at the top to keep them firmly in place in my diaper pail. The only drawbacks I found were that they took a while to air dry and could leak if every diaper and insert weren’t cleaned first. Avoid placing these bags in the dryer as doing so could cause the lamination to peel off and affect their waterproofness. The fabric strip holding the snaps ripped off after several washes, but other than that, the bags have been useful and are still serving their purpose.
The bags have remained usable and have done a good job of fulfilling their purpose despite a little problem with the fabric strip securing the snaps ripping off after multiple washes.
Related Post: The Best Diaper Pail: Diaper Genie vs Ubbi
Teamoy Reusable Pail Liner: Best Standalone Liner
If you prefer a standalone liner without a diaper pail, the Teamoy Reusable Pail Liner is an excellent choice. These durable and waterproof liners can be attached to towel bars, hooks, racks, or changing tables throughout your home. The set includes two machine-washable pail liners, ensuring you always have a backup. They come in various colors and styles to match your decor.
PROS
CONS
Community Feedback: “I’ve been using this set of waterproof pail liners for a while now, and they’ve been a great addition to my home.”
Ninja Mama Bamboo Carbon Charcoal Diaper Pail Filter: Powerful Carbon Deodorizer
For discreet odor control, the Ninja Mama Bamboo Carbon Charcoal Diaper Pail Filter is an excellent option. These odorless bamboo carbon filters effectively eliminate smells and last for half a month. You can recharge them in the sun for an additional 15 days of use. With a pack of 12 filters, you’ll have year-long odor protection. These filters can be taped to the lid or placed in the bottom of the pail.
PROS
CONS
Community Feedback: “As a pet owner with a senior rescue dog who needs disposable belly bands, controlling odor has been a constant struggle.”
A cloth diaper pail is a specialized container designed for storing soiled cloth diapers until they can be washed. Unlike disposable diapers, which are simply thrown away in a regular trash can, cloth diapers need a dedicated storage solution due to the need for washing and reusing. Cloth diaper pails come in various types and can be used with different methods, depending on the user’s preferences. Here’s an overview of cloth diaper pails and how they work:
Types of Diaper Pails:
- Dry Pail Method: In this method, a cloth diaper pail is lined with a reusable, waterproof liner, and soiled diapers are stored dry inside the pail. It’s essential to remove any solid waste from the diapers before placing them in the pail to prevent it from going into the washing machine.
- Wet Pail Method: This method involves pre-soaking the soiled cloth diapers in water within the diaper pail. The presence of water and pre-soaking help minimize stains and odors. However, it’s crucial to change the pail water daily to reduce unpleasant smells. There’s a potential drowning hazard for young children with this method, so some diaper pails come with locks for safety.
- Combination of the Two: If you prefer a combination of methods, you can rinse the diaper inserts to remove urine and then place them in a wet pail. The diaper covers and shells can be stored separately in a dry bag.
How to Choose the Best Cloth Diaper Pail: When selecting a cloth diaper pail, consider the following factors:
- Method Preference: Decide whether you prefer the dry pail or wet pail method, or a combination of both. Your choice will determine how you manage soiled diapers.
- Laundry Frequency: Consider how often you plan to do laundry. If you want to wait several days between washes, you’ll need a pail that can hold a larger number of diapers.
- Deodorizing Method: Some diaper pails come with built-in deodorizers and specific refills, while others do not. You can also purchase individual deodorizers to place in the pail or use built-in ones.
- Pail Features: Ensure that the cloth diaper pail you choose has the features you prefer, such as a deodorizer, a lid lock, or a childproof design.
- Liner Compatibility: Pick a liner for your diaper pail after purchasing the pail itself to ensure it fits properly. Most liners are universal, but it’s better to check compatibility.
Do Diaper Pails Need Liners? While not mandatory, using a liner in your cloth diaper pail offers several benefits:
- Less Cleanup: Liners protect the inside of the pail, reducing the need to clean it as frequently.
- Easier Washing: Liners allow you to easily remove the soiled diapers and carry them to the laundry room without touching each one individually.
- Odor Control: Some liners can be scented, and others are designed for efficient use with deodorizers, helping combat odors.
- Related Post : Diaper Genie Elite vs Complete: Unveiling the Distinctions
How Many of Each Are Needed?
- Pails: The number of pails you need depends on your preferences. While one pail is sufficient, having two can be more convenient if you want to dispose of diapers in multiple rooms.
- Liners: You technically only need one liner, but having a second as a backup can be helpful, especially when one is in the wash.
- Deodorizers: Many pails have built-in deodorizers, so you only need to replace those. If your pail lacks built-in deodorizers or you want extra odor control, you can purchase deodorizers individually. Deodorizers typically last about three months, so having four on hand can help you cover a year.
In conclusion, choosing the right cloth diaper pail and related accessories is essential for a smooth cloth diapering experience. By considering your preferences, laundry routine, and the features you need, you can find the best cloth diaper pail that suits your needs and keeps your baby’s nursery smelling fresh.
Conclusion
Choosing the right cloth diaper pail, liner, and deodorizer can make your diapering journey smoother and more pleasant. Consider your specific needs, such as odor control, diaper capacity, and eco-friendliness, when selecting the best option for your family. With the right products in place, you can focus on what truly matters – keeping your baby comfortable and happy.
FAQs
1.Cloth diaper pails and liners are often more eco-friendly than disposable diaper systems. Many are designed for long-term use and can reduce the environmental impact of diapering.
2.While cloth diaper pails are designed for cloth diapers, some can also accommodate disposable diapers with the appropriate liners.
3.The frequency of changing the diaper pail deodorizer depends on the product. Some need recharging every 12 to 15 days, while others last longer. For optimum results, adhere to the manufacturer’s recommendations.
3.The frequency of changing the diaper pail deodorizer depends on the product. Some need recharging every 12 to 15 days, while others last longer. For optimum results, adhere to the manufacturer’s recommendations.
4.Yes, you can use diaper pail liners as standalone bags for storing dirty diapers until laundry day. They are versatile and can be hung from hooks or towel bars.
5.Carbon filters in diaper pails are effective at reducing odors, but their effectiveness may vary based on the brand and model of the pail. Some may require multiple filters for strong odors.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.


Leave a Reply